Featuring Property Focus AI™
Shelter Island Housing Market Trends
Market Summary
Property Focus is a top real estate property search platform that provides in-depth property insights, transaction histories, and ownership data across the U.S. In the past 12 months, Shelter Island saw 37 residential properties sold. As of June 2025, the median price for a single-family home is $1,525,000, with a median AVM value of $1,714,500 for properties sold in the last year.
There are 0 involuntary liens on 0 properties, 0 in pre-foreclosure, and 2,199 properties with more than 50% equity in Shelter Island. The market also includes 1,466 fully paid-off homes, offering unique opportunities for buyers and investors.
Market Stats Overview
Total Residential Properties
2,588
Total Home Sales
37 12 mo. trend
Median Home Price
$1,525,00012 mo. trend
Average Loan-to-Value
9.59%
Current Pre-foreclosures
0
% of Properties in Distress
0%
Total Involuntary Liens
0
% of High Equity Homes
84.97%
Markets Nearby Shelter Island
Explore real estate market data for cities, counties, and zip codes neighboring Shelter Island. Each location features detailed market statistics, sales trends, pre-foreclosure information, and other property information to help understand current housing conditions. These adjacent markets share regional connections with Shelter Island, providing valuable context and insights into the broader real estate landscape.